A 10-Year Performance Comparison for GCC Investors

Quick Answer: How Has TASI Compared to the S&P 500 Over 10 Years?

  1. The S&P 500 significantly outperformed TASI over the 10-year period 2016–2026, delivering higher cumulative returns with lower oil-price-linked volatility

  2. TASI's deepest drawdown exceeded 50% in 2016 when oil collapsed — the S&P 500's worst drawdown in the same period was approximately 34% in the 2020 COVID crash

  3. TASI offers higher dividend yields on average than the S&P 500, with several large constituents yielding 7–10%

  4. TASI and the S&P 500 are largely uncorrelated — TASI follows oil prices and regional geopolitics, the S&P 500 follows US tech earnings and Fed policy

  5. A GCC investor holding both gains diversification: TASI adds oil price exposure and SAR-denominated income; the S&P 500 adds USD growth and tech sector exposure

What you will learn in this article

  • The annual return of TASI vs S&P 500 for each year from 2016 to 2026

  • The key drivers behind each index's performance

  • Volatility, drawdowns, and dividend yield differences

  • What the 10-year data means for your Saudi/GCC portfolio allocation

  • The practical case for holding both, not choosing one

The S&P 500 outperformed TASI over the 10-year period from 2016 to 2026, but the comparison is more nuanced than a simple returns number suggests.

TASI and the S&P 500 are fundamentally different indices driven by different economic forces. TASI's performance is primarily linked to oil prices, Saudi government spending, and regional geopolitical stability. The S&P 500 is driven primarily by US corporate earnings, Federal Reserve monetary policy, and the performance of its mega-cap technology constituents.

Comparing them helps GCC investors understand not just which market performed better, but why and how owning both can produce a more resilient portfolio than choosing either alone. See also our guide to TASI vs US Stocks: Where Should Saudi Investors Put Their Money? for a decision-focused comparison.

Year-by-Year Performance: TASI vs S&P 500 (2016–2025)

Both indices had strong years and weak years but their cycles are driven by entirely different forces.

YearTASI Return (approx.)S&P 500 Return (approx.)Key Driver (TASI)Key Driver (S&P 500)
2016-50% (peak-to-trough drawdown)+12%Oil crash, fiscal austerityPost-election rally, financials
2017+6%+19%Oil stabilisation, reformsTax cuts, tech surge
2018-14%-6%oil volatilityFed tightening, trade war
2019+7%+29%Aramco IPO hype, Vision 2030Trade deal optimism, Fed pivot
2020-11%+16%COVID lockdowns, oil warTech mega-cap surge (WFH)
2021+30%+27%Oil recovery, post-COVID reboundEarnings boom, low rates
2022+16%-19%High oil prices (Russia/Ukraine)Fed rate hikes, tech crash
2023-4%+24%Oil cuts, tariff uncertaintyAI rally (NVIDIA, Microsoft)
2024+1%+23%Low oil, Aramco dividend cutAI continuation, S&P breadth
2025-13%-7% (estimate)Oil below $60, TASI 15-month lowTariff uncertainty, tech pullback

Key Structural Differences Between TASI and the S&P 500

Understanding why the returns differ is more useful than the returns themselves.

FactorTASIS&P 500
Primary return driverOil prices and government spendingUS corporate earnings and Fed policy
Largest constituentSaudi Aramco (~67% of index)Apple (~7% of index — much less concentrated)
Dividend yield (average)3–5% (top names yield 7–10%)~1.3–1.5%
CurrencySAR — pegged to USD at 3.75USD
Trading daysSunday to ThursdayMonday to Friday
10-year volatility (annualised)Higher — oil-linked swingsModerate — tech and earnings driven
Correlation with oil priceHigh (positive)Low to moderate (negative for consumers)
Sector weighting~65% energy, ~20% banking~30% tech, ~13% healthcare

TASI's Structural Advantages for Saudi Investors

TASI offers three things the S&P 500 cannot: oil price hedge, SAR-denominated dividends, and domestic economic alignment.

For a Saudi investor earning in SAR, TASI stocks pay dividends in SAR without currency conversion risk. For a Muslim investor, many TASI constituents, particularly the Islamic banks, are structurally Sharia-compliant. For an investor who understands Saudi macroeconomics and Vision 2030, TASI's domestic focus can be an advantage.

TASI also historically moves counter-cyclically to global tech-driven markets. In 2022, when the S&P 500 fell 19% on Fed rate hikes, TASI rose 16% driven by high oil prices from the Russia-Ukraine conflict. This natural hedge is structurally valuable in a mixed portfolio.

GCC context: Because the SAR is pegged to the USD at a fixed 3.75 rate, GCC investors in TASI effectively eliminate currency risk on their Saudi holdings. US stock gains in USD translate directly back to SAR at the same rate, which means TASI and S&P 500 returns can be compared without currency adjustment for most GCC-based investors.

Build a diversified portfolio with S&P 500 stocks and ETFs on one Raseed account — fees capped at $3. → Start investing on Raseed →

Should You Hold TASI or the S&P 500 — or Both?

The 10-year data suggests the most resilient GCC portfolio holds both, not one or the other.

TASI gives you oil price alignment, SAR income, and domestic Vision 2030 growth exposure. The S&P 500 gives you USD growth, tech sector returns, and global company diversification unavailable in Saudi markets. A portfolio holding 40–60% Saudi equities for domestic grounding and 40–60% US equities for growth has historically provided better risk-adjusted returns than a pure commitment to either market.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Has TASI ever outperformed the S&P 500?

Yes. In years of high oil prices, TASI has significantly outperformed. In 2022, TASI gained 16% while the S&P 500 fell 19%. In 2021, both gained approximately 27–30%. TASI's outperformance tends to coincide with oil above $80/barrel and rising Saudi government spending.

Q: Is it riskier to invest in TASI or the S&P 500?

TASI has historically been more volatile, largely due to its concentrated exposure to oil prices through Aramco's dominance. The S&P 500 is diversified across 500 companies in multiple sectors, though it carries significant tech concentration risk. Neither is inherently safer — they carry different types of risk.

Q: Can I invest in the S&P 500 index from Saudi Arabia?

Yes. Eligible investors in Saudi Arabia may be able to access S&P 500 exposure through ETFs or similar investment products, depending on product availability and the terms shown in the app.

Q: What is TASI's best 12-month return in the past 10 years?

TASI's strongest single-year performance in the 2016–2025 period was approximately 2021, when it gained around 30%, driven by oil price recovery from COVID lows and strong banking sector earnings as Saudi economic activity rebounded.

Related Articles on Raseed Learn

TASI vs US Stocks — Full Decision Guide

Best TASI Sectors to Invest In

Understanding Risk in Stock Trading

5 Steps to Diversify Your Portfolio

Disclaimer

This article is for educational and informational purposes only. It is not investment advice, nor a recommendation, offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security or digital asset. Investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

Securities brokerage services are provided by Fullerverse (SC) Limited, a securities broker-dealer licensed and regulated by the Financial Services Authority of Seychelles (Licence No. SD152). Fullerverse (SC) Limited is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Raseed Invest Inc. Registered address: House of Francis, Room 302, Ile Du Port, Mahe, Seychelles.

Cryptocurrency services are made available by Raseed Crypto LLC ("Raseed Crypto"), a FinCEN-registered money services business (MSB Registration No. 31000316890439) and a wholly-owned subsidiary of Raseed Invest Inc. Cryptocurrencies are not stocks and your cryptocurrency investments are not protected by either FDIC or SIPC. Cryptocurrency is highly speculative in nature and involves a high degree of risk, including volatile market price swings, market manipulation, flash crashes and cybersecurity risks. Cryptocurrency regulations are continuously evolving, and it is your responsibility to understand and abide by them. Cryptocurrency trading can lead to large, immediate and permanent loss of financial value. You should have appropriate knowledge and experience before engaging in cryptocurrency trading. For additional information, please see our Crypto Risk Disclosures.

Cryptocurrency services are not offered by, and are not available through, Raseed Invest Limited, which is regulated by the Dubai Financial Services Authority. Products and services referenced in this article are not available in all jurisdictions and are not directed at any person in a jurisdiction where their offer or availability would be contrary to local law or regulation.